Underdog Strikes Again!
It happened again!… and on a grander scale this time too!
In what can only be described as a monumental upset, Kris Allen achieved the impossible in pulling off the victory over Adam Lambert in yesterday’s American Idol finale. Unlike last year’s surprising victory by David Cook, this was a result almost nobody believed could happen, Kris Allen fans included.
Adam Lambert took the competition by storm from the Hollywood rounds into the top 12. He was the clear favorite from day one and he only solidified his hold of the lead with each spectacular performance.
Kris on the other hand flew well under the radar in the beginning of the competition, only to slowly pick up steam toward the later stages of the competition.
I remember his performance of Man in the Mirror in the qualifying stages. I thought he was good, but I didn’t think too much of it. I was surprised he made it into the top 12. (At the time, I was rooting for Danny Gokey and Matt Giraud to face off in the finale.)
Then Kris sang To Make You Feel My Love (one of my all-time favorite songs) on Country Week, and I became a fan. Still, I didn’t believe he’d make it past the top 8. But with Matt Giraud gone, I rooted for him hard, but didn’t expect he’d win. I honestly had to shout when they announced his victory. Imagine how you’d react after seeing someone hit a game-winning buzzer beater from the halfcourt in Game 7 of the NBA Finals, that’s how I screamed.
So, how exactly did Kris do it? Well, I’m no expert, but in the tradition I started last year here are a few of my thoughts on why Kris deserved to win American Idol.
1. Emotional Connection
As judge Kara DioGuardi put it, “If you don’t feel a thing after a Kris Allen performance, there is something wrong with you.”
If Kris had any strength, it was his ability to connect with the audience with his songs. While people watched in awe and amazement with every Adam Lambert performance, each Kris Allen performance left them relaxed and emotional. While Adam belted out his songs (and sang the lights out off each one), Kris seemed perfectly content with just sitting back and simply singing, caressing each note, letting the stories and messages of his songs resonate in the hearts of his audience. (See, To Make You Feel My Love, Falling Slowly, Ain’t No Sunshine) Adam, in contrast, seemed a little detached from his songs, despite the performances. Too theatrical, as the judges would put it, which is to say, it’s great to watch and listen to, but almost robotic and disconnected from the emotions of the songs. (common in musicals where actors do the same songs over and over. see, Lea Salonga)
Both Adam and Kris were terrific in creating song arrangements that suit them perfectly. (See Kris’ Heartless and Adam’s If I Can’t Have You) But while Adam’s performances left you with flashbacks of his performance, Kris’s singing almost always left you with a song you couldn’t get out of your head. His singing is the performance: no theatrics, no high notes, no bright lights necessary. Just Kris and the song. And it was always beautiful.
2. The Radio Factor
Connected to the reason I stated above, while Adam’s performances were always great to watch, Kris Allen’s singing was more moving to listen to. In the long run, people may have put more importance on that. After all, we’re going to listen to them on the radio or on ipods, mp3’s or CD’s more often than we will get to see them perform live or on television.
Try listening with your eyes closed, you’ll find Kris Allen is better hands down.
3. Momentum
Adam Lambert was the consensus favorite from day one, with perhaps a Danny Gokey vote every now and then. But through those unbelievable performances (im running out of adjectives already), Adam simply took the competition by storm and made all those who performed before him look like opening acts, while reducing those who came after him to mere afterthoughts. He peaked early, but the problem was he pretty much flat-lined from there. You saw one Lambert performance, you saw them all. It just so happened, they were all amazing.
Kris on the other hand started slow, then slowly picked up steam. He got better and better from week to week. You need only compare his performances of Man in the Mirror and Heartless to see what I’m talking about.
It’s not inconceivable that people simply began to grow tired of Adam (ditto, Danny), while taking notice of this other guy who was suddenly turning up his performances and making them pay attention.
4. Danny Gokey
Many people, myself included, thought American Idol was destined for a Gokey-Lambert face-off in the final. Few dared to disagree. Other than Adam, it was Danny who consistently excelled week after week. With one emotional power ballad after another. But with Kris Allen gaining momentum (see previous), Danny fell victim to his rise since having them both in the final would have been almost redundant.
And with Danny gone, it isn’t hard to imagine that many of the Gokey fans shifted their allegiance to Kris. Only 100,000 votes separated Kris and Adam in the top 3, and the additional support from Danny’s ouster may have been enough to carry Kris past Adam in the final count.
5. Conspiracy Theory?
Conspiracy theorists will love this one. But you could easily make a case for both contenders. Adam Lambert fans will point to certain pictures and videos that surfaced on the internet as the ones that ruined his chances. Kris Allen supporters on the other hand will point to the [VERY] bad producer’s song choice for Kris in the finale, coupled with the key that was one or two notches too high for him on the winner’s song as evidence that the show’s producers were trying to sabotage Kris’ chances.
I don’t believe in these conspiracy theories, but they’re fun to consider.
6. The Underdog Factor
And finally, the factor I think was the biggest key to Kris Allen’s upset victory. Whether or not he did it on purpose, Kris played the underdog card to perfection in the finale. Kris looked like he had resigned himself to inevitable defeat and was just giving it his all on his final performances, which were sidebars to Adam’s excellence. Beginning with that heart-rending, haunting encore performance of To Make You Feel My Love (See, number one), followed by him making the most of the producer’s [SERIOUSLY BAD] song choice. (How could they possibly screw that up any worse? I could put my ipod on shuffle and I bet the first ten songs to play would still be a better fit for Kris to sing. What’s Going On simply didn’t allow him to do anything with it. As opposed to the terrific choice for Adam Change is Gonna Come.)
Then to top it all off, Kris poured out his heart and soul on that final performance of the winner’s single, on an arrangement that seemed to be made for Adam Lambert. He just let it all hang out, and he was inspiring to watch.
(As opposed to Adam’s completely detached and uninspiring rendition of the same song. He performed it brilliantly, but still, it felt empty to me. And I’m beig copmpletely objective here. Adam did better on Tracks of my Tears and If I Can’t Have You.)
This battle royale turned into the classic big city favorite going up against the small town dreamer. People can always relate with the dreamer, and they were no different with Kris Allen. Admit it, you LOVE underdog success stories.
In the end, Kris Allen’s victory only cemented what we all already know. That anything’s possible. And that we should never give up on our dreams.
GO KRIS! Can’t wait for your album..
Ditto Matt and Danny.. ’til next year!